Page : 1
(Cover Page)
Department Of English
Name of Institution :................................................................................
MA (Final) Year
TERM
PAPER
ON
“Modern life depicted in Modern Poetry.”
Submitted to:
Name of Teacher...........................
Lecturer/Assistant/Associate Professor
Department of English
Name of Institution.........................
Prepared by:
Name of the Student...................................
Class Roll :...............
Session :.................................
Department of English
Name of institution........................................
Page : 2
Department
of English
Govt Edward College, Pabna
Declaration
I hereby
declare that the concerned term paper
entitled “Modern life depicted in Modern Poetry.” is a work of ………………..
a student of MA [Final] Year, Department of English, Govt Edward
College, Pabna. He/She
has completed his/her term paper under my supervision and submitted for the
partial fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of Master of Arts [MA]
under National University,
Gazipur, Bangladesh.
Name of the Teacher.........................
& Signature: ................................
Page : 3
Abstract
Modernism
is a remarkable shift from the traditional forms of writing in English
literature. William Butler Yeats (1865-1939), Robert Frost, Dylan Thomas, Seamus Heaney, and Thomas
Stearns Eliot (1888-1965), Wystan Hugh Auden are some of important poets in modern period. Moreover,
World War I has important role in shattering traditional beliefs. As a result, values,
conventions and life style have changed. Moreover, scientific innovation has
important role to bring social changes. Many modem writers have been influenced by the crisis of
early twentieth century society.
Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to focus on how a few major modern
poets have responded to modem life.
Page 4
Table of Contents
Introduction------------------------------------------------------------------------------ (page no)
Chapter l:
World War I, Modernism and Modern Literature----------------------4
Effect of World War 1 on Traditional
Society-----------------------------4
Rise of
Modernism----------------------------------------------------------------------6
Chapter 2: Representation of Early 20th Century Society in Modern
Poetry-----8
Chapter3: Depiction of Modern Life in modern Poetry--------------------------10
Depiction
of Modern Life in Yeats-----------------------------------------10
Depiction of
Modern Life in Eliot-------------------------------------------13
Depiction of
Modern Life in Frost------------------------------------------17
Depiction
of Modern Life in Auden------------------------------------20
Conclusion --------------------------------------------------------------------24
Bibliography-------------------------------------------------------------------------25
Appendix-------------------------------------------------------------------------26
Introduction
Modernism
is an important movement, which started from the last quarter of the nineteenth
century. It is a dramatic shift from the traditional form of writing. According
to Barry, modernism is an “earthquake in the arts which brought down much of
the structure of pre-twentieth-century practice in music, painting, literature,
and architecture. The center o f the
earthquake was in Vienna but it influenced other
European countries including England.
Even now its shock-waves can be felt somewhere around the world. Modernism is a
remarkable change in social values, culture and literature:
The specific features signified by “modernism” (or by
the adjectives modernist) vary with the user, but many critics agree that it
involves a deliberate and radical break with some o f the traditional bases not
only o f Western art, but o f Western culture in general. (Abrams 167) Due to
scientific research, the last decade of the nineteenth century experienced “a
running controversy as to whether the
basic material of the
universe behaved like waves
or particles; a controversy for which there was no direct observation.”
(Bell 11) Beside the technological innovations, the
catastrophe o f World War I is often blamed for this dramatic shift.
World War I has played an important role in shattering
traditional beliefs. In the field o f literature, many changes have taken
place. Modern writers are more interested to portray the post-war society in
their writings. As traditional beliefs have been shattered by the
catastrophe o f the World War I, many
forbidden subjects have been introduced in the field of art. People
have preferred realism instead of
romanticism and morality tales.
In modem
poetry, one o f the
important aspects is the
use o f classical myth
in portraying post-war society. Myth, legend and folklore are not same.
Legend is a fable based on normal human
being rather than supernatural being. The protagonist is a normal human being
in a legend. For example, the story o f Joan of Arc is a legend. Usually a legend has
historical background. On the
other hand, folklore
is a fable
based on supernatural incidents. But
the supernatural beings are not gods and goddesses. For example, some stories of
Lilith are folklore. If the story is about gods and goddesses then
it is termed religions. For example, the story of the Greek god Zeus had
religious value in ancient time. According to Abrams, “a mythology is a
religion in which we no longer believe.”
But legend, folklore and mythology has
important role in controlling social behavior:
Most myths are related to social rituals-set forms and
procedures in sacred ceremonies-but anthologists disagree as to whether rituals
generated myths or myths generated rituals. (Abrams 170) This dissertation will
focus on the depiction o f modem civilization in modem poetry. The first
chapter of this paper will briefly discuss the concept o f modernism. The
chapter will focus on the consequence o f World War I on traditional society,
the rise of modernism and some important aspects o f modem literature. The
second chapter will briefly discuss how modem poetry has responded to the early
20th century world.
The chapter
will focus on the representation o f society
in modem poetry, some important features in modem poetry and the importance of
mythological elements in modem poetry. The third chapter will focus on the
poetry of William Butler Yeats (1865-1939), William Carlos Williams (1883-1963),
Ezra Pound (1885-1927) and Thomas Steams Eliot (1888-1965). This chapter will examine how Yeats, Williams, Pound and Eliot have
responded to modem civilization such as mechanization, urbanization,
industrialization and secularization in their poetry.
Chapter 1
World War I, Modernism and Modern Literature
Modernism is
the era, which Harold Rosenberg describes as “the tradition of the new.” Modernism
evolves due to technological changes in the last quarter of nineteenth century.
Due to innovations, the society changes rapidly. Moreover, World War I has important effect on traditional society. The social changes made the
world very different from traditional
society.
Effect of World War I on Traditional
Society
Victorian society was a moralizing society. The
society was collectivist rather than individualistic. Women stayed at home
rather than working outside the home. Respectability was a strong force in the
Victorian era. People had a narrowed mindset in matters o f sexuality.
Moreover, society was very much class-based. As a result, morality became an
important element in Victorian literature. In contrast to Victorian literature,
modem literature was much artistic and realistic. In the modem era, society
changed rapidly. Women came outside the home and joined the workforce. They
also got suffrage (Women got suffrage in 1918 in England and in 1920 in America).
Due to the industrial revolution and urbanization, the labor force increased.
Poor people rowded the overcrowded slums
of the big cities.
They were
considered as a “lower order of humanity, and treated as such, valued only as
the vast pool of surplus labour on which the social as well as the economy
system depended.” (Bullock 61) The international economy expanded rapidly
during 1870 to 1913 compared to
former cades. Society started to
sympathize with androgyny and homosexuality. People started to emphasize on the individual
interest. Society started to accept unconventional people, who had been rejected in Victorian society:
The wanderer, the loaner, the exile, the restless and
rootless and homeless individual were no longer the rejects of self-confident
society but rather those who, because they stood outside, were uniquely placed
in an age when subjectivity was truth to speak with vision and authority. Perceptibly
in the nineties and even more markedly in the early years of the new century,
the custody o f life’s integrities began to pass from society to individual -
to an individual who necessarily commanded some unique perception of the things
of life, who embodied some secret essence which alone gave the world its
legitimization. (McFarlane 82) The basic of family life started to weaken
through the practice o f individualism.
Young people
started to concentrate on their own personal
interests neglecting prevalent social values. As a consequence, social
values started to change. Due to scientific research, people started to lose
their faith in their traditional values of love, fidelity and religion.
Moreover, many scientific theories opposed many prevalent traditional values. The final attack on their beliefs was
the tremendous violence of World War I. People observed for the first time
bombing from airplanes. Violence o f the war was no longer limited to only
fighters but reached to the doors o f common people. The tremendous human
misery and suffering brought by the war shattered the traditional values:
The Great War which tore Europe apart between 1914 and
1918 was so shattering in its
impact, so far-reaching
in its consequences, that
it is profoundly difficult to recapture what proceeded it -
difficult to avoid exaggerating the sense o f the conflict in
the pre-war years, difficult not to see them
building up into a general crisis of European society in which a crash,
a resolution by force, was inevitable and felt to be inevitable. (Bullock 58) The
war affected society severely. It took a lot from human being but returned
almost nothing. As a result, modern man was growing up cut off from their
culture and tradition. They were known as the ‘lost generation’ as Earnest
Hemingway portrays them in The Sun
also Rises (1926). Many modem writers describe the modern world as the
apocalyptic time.
W. B Yeats, who
observed both the
Victorian era and the modem
era, portrayed the anarchy o f modem time in his poem “The
Second Coming”:
Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot
hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and
everywhere
The ceremony of innocence drowned;
The best lack all the conviction, while
the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
(The
Second Coming)
The poem describes the nature of modem
era and the death o f traditional values. For eats, traditional values are more
important than the modem values. Culture and traditional values of the society
have been destroyed in modem times. It is often said that apocalypse has already
arrived in the modem era:
It (Dada or Surrealism) is the
art consequent o f Heisenberg’s ‘Uncertainty Principal’, of the destruction of
civilization and reason in the First
World War, o f the world changed and reinterpreted by Marx, Freud and Darwin,
of capitalism and constant industrial acceleration, o f existential exposure
to meaninglessness of absurdity. (Bradbury and McFarlane 27). The
war changed human culture completely. Many people had to migrate from one
country to another. People growing up during the war period (1914-1919) lost
their cultural values. As a result, social values started to degrade rapidly.
Rise of Modernism
The word ‘Modernity’ was first used by Charles
Baudelaire (1821-1867) in the essay named ‘The Painter o f
Modem Life’ in the mid nineteenth century. He describes “modernity as the fashionable,
fleeting and contingent in art, in opposition to the eternal and immutable.”
(Childs 14) Modem life is described as the effect of urbanization
and technological advancement on human life:
In relation to Modernism, modernity is considered to
describe a way o f living and of experiencing
life which has arisen with the changes wrought by industrialisation, urbanisation and
secularisation; its characteristics are disintegration and reformation, fragmentation
and rapid change, emphatically and insecurity. It involves certain new understandings
o f time and space: speed, mobility, communication, travel, dynamism, chaos and
cultural revolution. (Childs 14-15) Beside the technological innovation,
modernism also includes the effect o f World War I on human society. Technology
has become a curse since World War I for common citizens of many
countries as Pound has portrayed in “The Return.” Observing the sudden violence of the war,
young people matured suddenly. Therefore,
modem art becomes different from traditional forms of art. Instead o f writing
romanticism (Austen’s Pride and
Prejudice) and morality tale (Bronte’s Jane Eyre), people start to focus on real life (Lawrence’s Sons and Lovers). Many innocent people have suffered due
to urbanization and innovations:
Indeed Modernism would seem to be the
point at which the idea o f the radical and innovating arts, the experimental,
technical, aesthetic ideal that had been
growing forward from Romanticism,
reaches formal crisis - in
which myth, structure and organization in a traditional sense collapse, and not
only for formal reasons.
(Bradbury and McFarlane 26)
Technology has
reached the common person’s house.
The lifestyle of everyone has changed
rapidly. Along with changing
society, art and literature also
starts to change.People become more
prone to come up with new
ideas. The past
is often eglected. Tradition has
lost its control on the human
soul. People started to believe, only what science allowed them to
believe: Modernity, in normal usage, is something that progresses in company
with and at the speed o f the years, like the bow-wave of a ship; last year’s
modem is not this year’s. (Bradbury and McFarlane 22) Modem people often deny
conventions o f former times. The impact o f scientific revolution is not limited within the field of science.
It starts to influence every fiber o f human life.
Many of the scientific theories ran
counter to traditional beliefs. As a result, people started to move away from
social conventions: The term ‘Modernism’ can hardly be taken
in the former sense; for in any working definition of it we shall have to see
in it a quality of abstraction and highly conscious artifice, taking us behind
familiar reality, breaking away from familiar functions of language and
conventions of form. (Bradbury and McFarlane 24) Modernism includes everything
that breaks the ground rules o f the Victorian era. People start to think
outside the boundary. Therefore, the movement of modernism becomes a turning point in English Literature.
Representation
of Early 20th Century Society in Modern Poetry
In modem poetry, one of the significant
features is representation of social changes due to technological innovations and
violence of World War
I. Modern man is not traditionalist. They often
oppose old values and
old customs. They are
much more
interested in material comfort rather
than spiritual comfort. As a result, material success
becomes the only goal o f the modern man although
it may be achieved in illicit
ways.
Many poets of the modern era have
portrayed these aspects o f modem man in their poetry: The world in which
modern poetry grew up was the world o f high bourgeois culture, the heir o f
all the ages, and possessed of the technical resources to become fully aware o
f its inheritance. (Hough 316)
Not only do social values
change but also the style of writing changes. People prefer to
read realistic forms o f
writing. They love to read everyday language instead of elevated
language. Romanticisms and
morals are ignored in the modern
era. Modern man
also ignores folklore and religious myths. Modern poetry is influenced
by these hanging social values: Hugh Selwyn Mauberley (written by Ezra Pound) is at times a
moving elegy for the world o f artistic and social possibility that the war
seemed to obliterate; Pound looks back with
a delicate combination of affection and
irony at earlier vanguard movements in
arts ... nothing
their inadequacies but excoriating the
culture that rejected their energies. (Longenbach 117-118)
Eliot’s The Waste Land is the best example of
portrayal o f modern society. The
Waste
Land portrays that modern people
are more associated with material profit.
Modern poetry also includes realism but artistic presentation of human life. Romanticism is often denied in
modern poetry. Modern poetry only deals with the reality of human life, rather
than the imagination. There may be imagination but it is connected with the
reality of human psychology, sufferings, happiness or emotions. For example,
Pound has used romanticisms in “The River-Merchant’s Wife: A Letter”.
But the poem
describes the effect of urbanization and industrialization on village
life. According to Childs, Romanticism was rejected
as metaphysical, indulgent,
sentimental, mannered and overemotional, and its view of reality as
inherently mysterious, while life for the new poets was to be glimpsed in
definite visual flashes or images. Modern poetry shifts from the conventional
form of writing. Modern poetry often observes the effect o f World War I on
every sphere of society including the field of literature. It often uses
metaphysical elements, which is comparable to those John Donne (1572-1631) used
in sixteenth century (His poems also contain irregular rhymes and meters). The
role of power is not new in the modern era. Many former writers could see that political
power is strong enough to abolish traditional values and religious beliefs.
Political leaders are often able to manipulate religion and
social culture.
In modem era.
World War I becomes a strong force to abolish the traditional beliefs, creating
the ‘lost generation’: A comparison with
Wordsworth is inevitable, for modern poetry’s response to the First
World War plays out a drama that was enacted by romantic poetry’s response to the French
Revolution. As the
utopian dreams inspired
by the Revolution
were demolished by the Reign of Terror, Wordsworth (like many of his
contemporaries) lost faith in the power of political action to effect social
change; the result was (as M.H. Abrams and Jerome McGann have demonstrated in different ways) that poets looked to poetry to carry the burden
of spiritual and cultural enlightenment.
(Longenbach 109) Modern poets often have the tendency to use myths in their
poetry. For example, Yeats has borrowed
elements from the Greek myth in “Leda and the Swan” in order to portray power relationship.
Modem people do not believe in their religion and traditional values. They consider
that romanticisms and morals are utopian ideas that cannot be achieved in
reality. Therefore, they often ignore
their traditional beliefs and focus on material profits.
According to Hough, Classical culture has lost its
unique authority; there is no ecumenical religion; the psychologists and
anthropologists have revealed systems of symbolism anterior to the accepted
cultural structures. (316) Modern writers often try to relate the disaster of
modern times with the disasters of former times. Sometimes, they suggest that
modern people should not forget their past because it is not easy to ignore
their past: Where Eliot’s long historical perspective
creates a powerful sense of the inescapable presence of the traditions embodied
in the mind of Europe, against which the present is evaluated, Crane’s
(American Poet, Hart Crane: 1899-1932)
wilful mythologizing presses what o f the
past can be
made to work
into the service
o f an eclectic imagination that
celebrates the untrammelled future. (Hyde 345) Modern poetry often portrays the
features of modern life. It often observes the effect of World War I on human
mind, crisis in human relationship and crisis in religious beliefs and traditional
beliefs.
Depiction of Modern Civilization in Modern Poetry
William Butler Yeats
(1865-1939), William Carlos Williams (1883-1963),
Ezra pound (1885-1927) and Thomas Stearns Eliot (1888-1965) are four
important poets in the modern period. They have depicted modern civilization in
their poetry.
Depiction of Civilization in Yeats
William
Butler Yeats portrays the
nature of modern civilization in his
poetry. Through mythological
elements and historical events, Yeats
portrays the importance of tradition in human life: The assumption of
presence in the peasant world is related to the idea that rural people are closer to nature
than their urban neighbors and the writer’s job is to recover
their original plentitude.
Thus the literature
becomes an act of mythic recovery. (Hirsch 882) Modern
people think that mythology has nothing to do with modem society. It does not bring
material comfort. As a result, Yeats has uses mythological elements in his
poetry in order to restore myth. But, he creates his own style: Yeats would
remake his style over and over again throughout his career, but his pristine syntax,
fulfilling the formal
demands of the poem
effortlessly, would remain
constant. (Longenbach 105)
He has
used old mythology but has given a new meaning and a modem aspect so that it
can be used in describing the modern times. His attempt to use classical
elements in modern poetry is meant to resurrect old myths and blend them with
history. In the poem “The Man and the Echo” the speaker tries to gain
spirituality. He prays to God to purify his soul. But he is unable to
communicate with God because he does not know where to seek God. He goes to
pray in Knocknarea in County
Sligo. According to Heaney,
“this rock face does not issue any message from the gods.” (Heaney 96) As a result,
the speaker finds nothing but the echo of his own words: The echo marks the
limits of the mind’s operations even as it calls the mind forth to its utmost
exertions, and the strenuousness of this dialectic issues in a poem that is asshadowed
by death as Larkin’s (English poet, Philip Larkin: 1922-1985) “Aubade,”
but is far more vital and undaunted.
“The
Man and the Echo” tries to make
sense of historical existence
within a bloodstained
natural world and an
indifferent universe. (Heaney 96) The speaker goes to revive his religious and
historical sense in his old age. But he does not have any guide to show his way
to purification. But he is still searching for his answer. But the speaker
finds a hint from the echo. Echo says “(I)ie down and die”, suggesting that
there is no possibility o f purification. The next echo suggests that his time
of purification is lost “into the night”. According to Heaney, in his old age
Yeats was searching for historical events in Ireland. In the poem “The Second
Coming”, Yeats portrays the post-war situation. He has used mythological
elements in the poem. The title reminds the reader of the return of Jesus Christ at the time o f anarchy. The title o f the poem
suggests that modem time is apocalyptic time. But Yeats has not suggested the
title for Jesus Christ: If we hold rigidly to the notion that only the poet’s
full mental experience can give the adequate symbol for the idea the title
suggests, then we must not call up some conventional painting o f Christ in a
glory.
No; we must pronounce the words “The Second
Coming!” and follow precisely Yeats’s own experience when he writes: I began to
imagine, as always at my left side just out o f the range o f the sight, a
brazen winged beast that I associated with laughing, ecstatic destruction.
(Stauffer 229) He has suggested the title for a cycle of history. Yeats borrows
the figure o f the Sphinx from the Theban play, Sophocles’s Oedipus Rex. The sphinx stands for
destruction. The poem depicts the anarchy of modem civilization. The poem
suggests the destruction of the former world as the consequence of the World
War I. Yeats uses historical
elements in his
two poems “Sailing
to Byzantium” and “Byzantium”. At the very beginning of the
poem “Sailing to Byzantium”,
the speaker says that it “is no country for old men.”
The
country has become the realm o f young people. The tradition is becoming dead.
Therefore, the speaker is going to the country of dead people, who are more
important than the living people. According to Jeffares, He is old, and,
besides being worried over his future career as a poet, is probably envious of
the fervour of human lovers. With his revision comes his desire for some degree
of secrecy, and his wish to crystallize his thought on a more general plane. The
statement above is a comment on the original draft of “Sailing to Byzantium” which was
preserved by Mrs. Yeats. According to Stauffer, Yeats has used “water imagery
for youth and life” (Stauffer240) and “fire, stone, and
metal imagery for age and intellect and art, seeing himself standing in the
great church of Sancta Sophia in Constantinople, with its mosaic saint on the
walls” (Stauffer240):
O sages standing in God’s holy fire
As in the gold mosaic of a wall,
Come from the holy fire, perne in a gyre,
And be the singing-masters o f my soul.
(Sailing
to Byzantium)
In the post-war society, the poet feels
alienated. Therefore, he wishes to sail to the country of dead people, Byzantium. Therefore, he
chooses the historical place Byzantium as an ideal land: Yeats, in fact, selected
material from his general impression of historical Byzantium which was most concerned with his
own situation. The marble stair, the jetty and the Cathedral were not
essential; they added nothing to the poet’s account of his problem; as symbols they were more
suited to the less directly subjective ‘Byzantium’. (Jeffares 47-48) The
speaker considers the new generation as a “dying generation” who have forgotten
their past. For the speaker, dead people in Byzantium are more important than the living
people. He wishes to live in the “holy city of Byzantium” to achieve eternity.
wishes to turn himself into a “golden
bough to sing”. The bird imagery reminds the reader of Keats’s “Ode to a Nightingale”, where the
speaker goes into his
reverie through the
song of nightingale. The poem “Byzantium” refers
to the city of Byzantium.
Now the speaker
has reached the city of Byzantium.
He will achieve his eternity here. According to Jeffares, Yeats has collected
most of his information about Byzantium
from The Age o f Justinian and
Theodora by W. G. Holmes. At the beginning of the poem “Byzantium”,
Yeats has given us a description of Byzantium
through “great cathedral gong”. The description of Byzantium city aims to restore the tradition of the Byzantium that
modern people has forgotten. Later in
the poem he talks about the dead people from Byzantium, who are more important than the
living people. According to Yeats, modern people are living a dead life with a
dead soul: 1call it death-in-life and life-in-death. (Byzantium) However, modern people are living
a dead life, killing their souls. But people of Byzantium are dead but still alive. The bird
and the tree are used as the symbols of eternity that are not free from the
disadvantages of the natural bird. Natural bird and tree can decay and die gradually.
Therefore, the speaker wishes to turn the bird in “golden handiwork” and the
tree into “golden bough”. Moreover, the songs of the bird and the fruit of the
tree are something that can achieve eternity.
In the same way,
a human being’s creativity can
give him eternity. Unfortunately,
modern people are more interested in material comfort. The poem has reference o
f the post-war situation of Irish society. Ireland
is colonized by England.
Here, the Greek god Zeus becomes symbol of the colonizer. It also suggests that
England is a powerful
country that is strong enough to colonize Ireland.
On
the other hand, Leda, a human being becomes the symbol for Ireland. The
illustration suggests that Ireland
lacks the ability to resist being colonized as Leda lacks ability to prevent
being violated: In other words, Yeats questions the limits o f poetic thinking
to transform and resist the violence o f material reality. By emphasizing the
brutal violence o f the rape, he deviates from the tradition of idealizing Leda
and Z eus’s union. In general in the poetry, Yeats looks for ways to resist England’s colonizing of Ireland, but he is acutely aware that his language is
sim ultaneously an agent o f his oppression, as well as a mode of resistance.
Leda’s lack o f clear resistance to the swan’s rape illustrates the impossibility
of resistance without complicity. (Neigh 153)
Not only does the colonization o f Ireland occur, but also the national identity o
f Ireland
is destroyed. The poem also suggests that after being violated by Zeus, Leda is
not the same. In the same way, Ireland
is not the same as it used to be: For Yeats, the drop forms a moment to imagine
other modes of being before he hits the
ground and must take on the fiction of his
national Irish identity to fight colonialism . The drop is where new collective occurs between identification and identity, between desiring the other and
falling away from that other, as a separate being. The drop becomes a way to
imagine the excess produced by the process of identification that does not
“fit” into one’s identity. (Neigh 153) Neigh
also says that
Yeats raises questions
about the ethics
of self and other in the
relationship between Leda and Zeus: “Zeus is both colonizer and patriarch,
while Leda is both feminine other and colonized.” (Neigh 155)
Depiction of Civilization in Eliot
Thomas Stearns Eliot portrays the crisis o f human
relationship in the modern world in his poetry.
Eliot uses many classical elem
ents in his poetry, which is one of the major features in modern
poetry. According to Harmon, The fact may be
that a poet is part of the normative magical and religious organization of a primitive society
and that his functions-to entertain, memorialize, decorate, conjure, and educate-ecumenism
caressingly unimportant as civilization grows and branches. (802) However, the style o f his poetry is different from the
classical form of writing. He uses images in
his poetry but
he is not
an imagist. His poetry
gives features of modern civilization. Eliot’s “The Love
Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” focuses on
city life. According to Harmon,
Prufrock characterizes a modem
man living in some European
or American society. According to
Oser, the poem “records his altered social and emotional responses to his ative
surroundings as well as an accom panying shift from moral to aesthetic
concerns.” The epigraph o f the poem is about Guido da Montefeltro. Montefeltro
was condemned to the eighth circle o f Hell for giving false counsel to Pope
Boniface VIII. According to Schneider, The Love Song is more than a retreat from love, however; it is the
portrait o f a man in Hell, though until this truth is clearly realized, the
hell appears to be merely the trivial one o f the self-conscious individual in
a sterile society. Prufrock does not analyze himself, we are not led into
peripheral guessing in Freudian or other terms about what may be wrong with
him: and we simply come to know directly what
it feels like to be
Prufrock. (1104) The epigraph indicates that Prufrock compares city life with
the life in hell.
The poem has allusion from the classical literature,
historical events and myth, in order to portray the post-war society: The
social images are lightly ironic, but these extreme ones are not: they form a
pattern of which the two main components are objective correlatives for a self
divided state and a state of paralysis or stagnation. (Schneider 1104) Laurence Perrine and Johan Schimanskr identify some references
in the poem. The phrase “time for all
the works and days of hands” refers to the long poem by the Greek
poet Hesiod. The poem is about agricultural life. Eliot compares the city life with the agricultural life. Usually, city life gives us a colorful
and luxurious image. But very few country people realize that the
city life may be as dull as country life. The poem also has the reference from
Shakespeare’s play Twelfth Night
: I know the voices
dying with a dying fall
(The
Love Song o f J. Alfred Prufrock)
City people are cut-off from their nature. As a result, they are living
a dead life. The poem
also refers to Oscar W ilde’s
play Salome. The speaker compares
him self with John the
Baptist:
Though I have seen my
head (grown slightly bald) brought in upon a platter,
I am no prophet—and here’s no great
matter;
(The Love Song o f J.
Alfred Prufrock)
But Prufrock is not a prophet or
reformer. He only represents a modem man, who silently
observes the crisis o f modem times. But he wants a
reformation that ends the crisis. Later,
Eliot has taken the element from M
arvell’s “To his Coy M istress” :
To have squeezed the universe into a ball
The line indicates that the modern people are not
inquisitive as renaissance people were.
They do not want to explore but want it explored. The
poem also has biblical element:
... “ I am Lazarus, come from the dead,
Come back to tell you all, I shall tell
you all”--
(The Love Song o f J.
Alfred Prufrock)
The poem “The
Love Songs of J. Alfred
Prufrock” portrays the crisis of modern civilization. According to
Childs, the poem also is an example of “crisis of discourse” (101) in modern
poetry. He also says that Prufrcok has failed to find right words to express
his “intense feelings of inadequacy.” (101) Eliot’s The Waste Land focuses on the crisis of human relationship in
modern land. The four chapters o f the
poem, “THE BURIAL OF THE DEAD”, “A GAME OF CHESS”, “THE FIRE SERM ON” and
“DEATH BY W ATER” refer to the four elements black bile (earth), air (phlegm),
red bile (fire), and water (blood),
respectively. It was traditionally believed
that human being is made of these four elements.
Moreover, Eliot has used a lot of myths in the poem: Using
mythology and pre- to early modern
culture, from the Fisher King and
the Holy Grail through to Dante and Shakespeare, Eliot creates a form in the
poem which aims both to master
the content and to
patch together all the many scraps of experience contained in the five parts. The epigraph is from a myth based work named Satyricon. The myth is about a woman,
a Sibyl, who grows but never dies. The epigraph
is dedicated to the culture of a
society, which changes over time but never dies. The title “THE BURIAL OF THE
DEAD” “develops the them e of the attractiveness o f death” (Brooks 187). The speaker describes the modern waste
land as “stony rubbish” where “dead tree gives no shelter” . Madame Sosostris
is not interested in the true meaning of the tarot card. She is only interested
in earning money, which she earns through false reading of Tarot cards: But the
symbols of the Tarot pack are still unchanged. The various characters are still
inscribed on the cards, and she is reading in reality, though she does not know
it, the fortune of the protagonist. She finds that his card is that o f the
drowned Phoenician Sailor, so she warns him against death by water, -not
realizing any more than do the other inhabitants o f the modern waste land that
the way into life may be by death itself. (Brooks 189) The “ Unreal City”
refers to the city from Baudelaire’s “The Seven Old M en”.
According to Brooks, the phrase may indicate fusion o
f dream and reality in modem life. The
image of the planting corpse in the garden and Mylae, the First Punic War
refers to the massacre of World War I.
In the World War I, not only have people died but also their beliefs and tradition have
been shattered. The chapter “THE GAME OF CHESS” deals with human relationship
in modern times. Chess game is considered a game o f sexes portraying power
relationship. The title also refers to one o f the four elements, air. It is
believed that intelligence comes from air. The section
deals with two
women. The first
woman is compared to
Cleopatra from Shakespeare’s play Antony and Cleopatra:
The Chair she sat in,
like a burnished throne,
(The Waste Land)
“The change o f Philomel, by the barbarous king” refers
to O vid’s Metamorphoses. Eliot
has related Philomel with the woman in
the “burnished throne” . It indicates that there is
something disappointing about this woman.
According to Brooks, If it is a commentary on how the waste land became waste,
it also repeats the theme of the death which is the door to life-the them e o f
the dying god. The raped woman becomes transformed through suffering into the
nightingale; through the violation comes the “ inviolable voice.” (Brooks 193) The relationship
between Lil and her husband
Albert portrays another aspect o
f human relationship. Lil’s friend advises her to make herself look good in
order to give “good tim e” to Albert. The relationship between Lil and her
husband Albert is not deep. This can be a commentary on
the modem marriage system .
Although, people get
married and have children, they do so as rituals.
The next section
“THE FIRE SERMON” deals
with lust of human being. The section refers to one of the elements,
fire. The physical love becomes a m atter of physical impulse or sinful
pleasure. Eliot starts with nature imagery but gives a vision of polluted and
barren nature. The image o f river does not give any reproductive or fruitful
impaction but polluted image. The
relationship between the speaker and Mr.
Eugenides is fruitless. The relationship between the typist and the clerk also
portrays the human lust rather than love. The couple are not interested in
family but an individual life. Moreover, Tiresias plays an
important role in the poem. He knows the past, present and future. He has the
experience of being man and woman. As a result, he can understand modern man
and woman and can relate the past, present and future: But in the note on
Tiresias, who appears in line 218 of the poem, Eliot implies that the poem is at the same time an exposition of the
state of mind of an individual: “Just as the one-eyed merchant, seller of
currants, melts into the Phoenician Sailor, and the latter is not only wholly
distinct from Ferdinand Prince of Naples, so all the women are one woman, two
sexes meets in Teiresias.” (Foster 569) The
reference to the relationship between Elizabeth and Leicester also portrays a
fruitless relationship. Elizabeth
did not get married because she did not want to share her power with an
other.
It also portrays human lust for power. The last section o f this
chapter portrays sexual violation, which is another aspect o f human lust. The
section “DEATH BY WATER”
symbolizes the resurrection o f the powers of nature. In the first line o f the
section, Eliot portrays the sacrifice o f the fertility god. But in the next
stanza he gives a hint o f the reincarnation o f the fertility god. According
to Brooks, Some specific connections can be made, however. The drowned
Phoenician Sailor recalls the drowned god o f the fertility cults. Miss Weston
tells that each year at Alexandria an effigy of the head o f the god was thrown
into the water as a symbol of the death o f the powers o f nature, and that
this head was carried by the current to By bolls where it was taken out of the
water and exhibited as a symbol o f the reborn god. (200) The modern
world is waste land
where “crops do
not grow, and
the animals cannot reproduce.” (Brooks 185)
Modern man has to
sacrifice the fertility
god so that
it can reincarnate in order to revive productivity. Eliot tries
to give probable
solutions to end
the crisis o f the
modem world in “ WHAT THE THUNDER
SAID .”
In the first section, he finds no hope o
f resurrection. He refers to the death o f Jesus Christ. Then, he tells about
the problem o f the modern life. Human soul is suffering everyday but body is
surviving. But survival is not the main m otif o f life. People, who had lived
a short life but had been able make an impression on an other, are still
living. However, modem man will be dead with the death o f their body. They
will not be remembered after their life. To end the crisis o f the modem land
the speaker gives three solutions from Sanskrit:
Datta (give), Dayadhvam (sympathy), and Damyata (control). These three
solutions deal with the spiritual
aspect, which modern people are missing. These three solutions are
able to bring peace on modem land. Eliot depicts the role o f time in modern
land in his Four Quartets.
The poem depicts that the modern people
cannot be detached from their past. In his Four Quartets he finds some
hope o f resurrection. According to
Melaney, the poem demonstrates
“how public events are hard to separate
from the history o f literature.”
(151) Eliot has borrowed the epigraph
from ancient cosmology: Eliot employs ancient cosmology as a framing device and
uses two fragments from Heraclitus as the poem ’s epigraph. (Melaney 153) The
Epigraph underscores the distinction between the people who accept that the
order of universe is common to all and the people who deny it.
Modern civilization is detached from
the former civilizations
by the violence
of warfare. The use o f
traditional elements in poetry
is an attempt to reunite the
classical civilization with the
modern civilization.
Eliot’s poems show that
modern world is not alienated from the
former world but modern land is the result o f historical event. According to
Harmon, For Eliot, the struggle to reach or rediscover such unification, which
is supposed to be common to primitive comm unities and to teach member of such
communities, is a problem for the poet
as an individual, for the poet as a member of a continuing culture informed by tradition, and for the
culture itself as it relates to its member, its history, and its neighbors.
(Harmon 803) Eliot has portrayed the crisis o f modern world but his aim is to
end of modern crisis. Yeats, Williams, Pound and Eliot have been responded by
modern civilization. They poems portray the
nature of modern society. These four writers
have broken the conventional form o f writing.
But they have not abandoned
their tradition, history and culture.
Depiction of Civilization in Frost:
In spite of the Pastoral element predominant in
Frost’s poems, he is still a modern poet because his poetry has been endowed
with the awareness of the problems of man living in the modern world dominated
by Science and Technology. However, he was a contemporary and friend to such
modernist greats as Ezra Pound and Wallace Stevens. But as a modern poet Frost
is different from other modern poets.
While modernist poetry is sometimes associated with an
elitist culture that takes poetry away from the general public through
experimental forms and esoteric references, Frost’s is a modern poet in his
rural, working-class persona, his traditional, metered voice and use of
colloquial phrases, as well as the mundane subjects of most of his poems.
The major
modern themes
The modern elements of his poetry are those of
capitalism, the self-centeredness of the modern man, the bored existence,
isolation, dilemma, and symbolism.
Two major
poems
The poems that seemed to me most striking modern in
nature are The Death of the Hired Man and Home Burial. The two poems are
similar in nature that in both of them there is a conflict between the husband
and the wife. Here the husbands represent a view of life which is very
antithetical to wives’. In the former poem there are three characters: Warren,
Mary and Silas. Warren, the domineering husband represent the capitalism ,Mary,
the cowed wife is a foil to her husband and Silas represent the lot of the
millions of the workers who are the victims of the modern capitalistic society
.Like Silas there are millions of the workers around the globe who toil and
toil ,but remain unrewarded and die an unlamented death.
Thus the central figure of the poem is Silas, whose
death the poem records. The character of Silas is very pathetic and sympathy arousing.
Silas in his old age, helpless and useless, is a pathetic decrepit figure
alienated from the world, with no shelter over his head and with no home to go
to. His self respect makes him feel ‘ashamed to please his brother’ and as a
result he is also isolated from his rich banker brother. It is true that Warren has some
accusations against Silas that he left the farm during the busy days. But in
this case Warren
also can’t fully understand Silas’s character. Why did he leave? He left for ht
higher wages. It shows that Silas was very poorly paid for his labor. So, Warren does not find any
fault in his own capitalistic manner by which he tried to buy the labor of
Silas in return of the little wages. In this way he represents the capitalist
society of the modern world.
The poem Home Burial is also based on a modern theme
namely the self-centeredness. Here the over-wrought wife is a foil to the
practical husband. They hold two diametrically opposite views of life. The wife
,under the burden of the grief over the death of her first new-born ,can’t
forget that her husband himself dug the grave of their own child in their
little grave-yard and himself buried him there. But to the husband, it seems a
normal act that he should have dug the grave of his own son. He has come to
accept the death of his son as an accident whose grief can be submerged beneath
the everyday existence of life.
In order to make his wife accept the accident the
husband gives some arguments. He says-
No, from the time when one is sick to
death
One is alone and he dies more alone.
Friends make pretence of following to the
grave
But before one is in it, their mind is
turned.
Thus the husband speaks out the selfish nature of the
modern men who even betray with the dead. All human sympathy is gone and it has
been replaced by selfishness. In this way the poem is a modern domestic epic,
which exposes some modern crises to our eyes.
Mending Wall
The poem Mending Wall is also very modern in its
approach. The poem is based on the modern theme of isolation. Modern men built
boundaries and made themselves isolated from each other. Frost’s metaphysical
treatment of this physical and psychological isolation is also an evidence of
his modernity. In “Mending Walls”, Frost juxtaposes the two opposite aspects of
the theme of the poem and then leaves it to the reader to draw his own
conclusion. The conservative farmer says:
Good fences make good neighbor
and the modern radical farmer says:
Something there is that doesn’t love a
wall,
But the question remains unsolved. And it is up to the
readers if they will keep the wall or pull down it.
Modern
approach to Nature
It is true that Frost’s poetry abounds in pastures and
plains, mountains and rivers, woods and gardens, groves and bowers, fruits and
flowers, and seeds and birds. But his approach to nature and this natural
phenomenon are different from the Romantics and is very realistic and modern in
nature. His retreat to the country side is not the romantic escape from the
harsh, unpleasant realities of modern life. The rural world, the world of
nature into which he withdraws, is not a world of dreams ,a pleasant fanciful
Arcadia ,but harsher and more demanding than the urban world. Unlike Romantics
he has taken notice of both the bright and dark aspects of nature as we see in
his poem “Two Tramps in Mud Time”. Beneath the apparently beautiful calm there
is lurking turmoil and storms:
Be glad of water, but don’t forget
The lurking frost in the earth beneath
In fact the world of nature in Frost’s poetry is not a
world of dream. It is much more harsh, horrible and hostile than the modern
urban world. Hence his experience of the pastoral technique to comment on the
human issue of modern world his realistic treatment of Nature, his employment
of symbolic and metaphysical techniques and the projection of the awareness of
human problems of the modern society in his poetry justly entitle him to be
looked up to as modern poet.
Problems of
Modern life
In fact, Frost’s poetry portrays the disintegration of
values in modern life and the disillusionment of the modern man in symbolical
and metaphysical terms as much as the poetry of great, modern poets does,
because most of his poems deal with persons suffering from loneliness and
frustration, regrets and disillusionment which are known as modern disease. In
“An old Man’s Winter Night”, the old man is lonely, completely alienated from
the society, likeness, the tiredness of the farmer due to over work in
“Apple-Picking” and as a result of it his yielding to sleep:
For I have too much
Of apple-picking: I am overtired
Of great harvest I myself desired.
The Poem The Road Not Taken also deals with the
dilemma of the modern mind. The poem depicts the confusion which prevails in
modern life. The modern man does not know which way to go and it is difficult
for him to make a choice. He is confused and his life does not have a clear
purpose. The speaker in the poem represents the modern man, who habitually
wastes energy in regretting any choice made, but belatedly and wishfully sighs
over the attractive alternative which he rejected:
I shall be telling this with a sigh Somewhere ages and
ages hence: Two roads diverged in a wood, and I—I took the one less traveled by,
And that has made all the difference.
Symbolism
The symbolic technique followed by Frost is also very
modern in nature. The poems that are rich in symbolic meaning are Mending Wall,
The Road Not Taken, Stopping by Woods by Snowy Evening, Birches etc. Mending
Wall is a symbolic poem in which he describes an anecdote typical of the
conservative approach of the rural people in New England, but it has the
universal symbolic implication. The poem Stopping By woods on a Snowy Evening
is also full of symbols. The poem symbolically expresses the conflict which
everyone feels between the demands of the practical life and a desire to escape
into the land of reverie. The closing stanza of the poem is especially
symbolic. The woods are lovely, dark and deep, But I have promises to keep, And
miles to go before I sleep, And miles to go before I sleep.
“The Road Not Taken” symbolizes the universal problem
of making a choice of invisible barriers built up in the minds of the people
which alienate them from one another mentally and emotionally thought they live
together or as neighbors in the society. Similarly the Birch trees in “Birches”
symbolize man’s desire to seek escape from the harsh suffering man to undergo
in this world.
Critics have a difference of opinion over considering
him a modern poet. Frost is a pastoral poet – poet of pastures and plains,
mountains and rivers, woods and gardens, groves and bowers, fruits and flowers,
and seeds and birds. They do not treat such characteristically modern subjects
as ‘the boredom implicit in sensuality’, ‘the consciousness of neuroses’ and
‘the feeling of damnation’. But the recent critical conversations have
resuscitated a little noted argument from the late seventies in favor of
viewing Frost as modernist.
While Frost does not place the whole course of Western
history into doubt or experiment with innovative formal structure and with the
position of the reader – characteristics of the work of other modernist poets
-- he does tend toward a critique of the increasing alienation of modern life,
as well as foster a sense of the visual that is so important to some groups of
modernists like the imagists (who favorably reviewed Frost’s work).
According to J.F.Lynen the use of the pastoral
technique by Frost in his poems, does not mean that the poet seeks an escape
from the harsh realities of modern life. He argues that it provides him with a
point of view. Frost uses pastoral technique only to evaluate and comment on
the modern lifestyle. His pastoralism thus registers a protest against the
disintegration of values in the modern society and here he is one with great
poets of the modern age like T.S.Eliot, Yeats and Hopkins.
Depiction of Civilization in Auden:
Wysten Hugh Auden is remembered as one of
the best American poets of the 20th century. Even much before the time that the
World War II broke out, Auden was engaged in highlighting various loopholes in
the political systems of the world which engendered flaws in the social
apparatus as well as the economic paraphernalia of any country. This article
carries out an exegesis into some of the ideas in W.H. Auden’s poetry, based on
his social analysis of the world.
The “Oxford Coterie “of young poets that
included Stephen Spenders and W.H. Auden together catalyzed the process of
introducing themes that are now archetypal to the modernist poetry of the 20th
century. One sees Auden’s poetry as beautiful and at times surreal on a
normative vision, but upon a deeper level of study, his poetry unravels its
underlying explanations to the problems that the world is confronted with. Not
only does Auden talk about the social and political problems but the problems
of identity, reclamation of space, and the herculean difficulties associated
with war-affected nations that breathe perpetual pessimism and existential
crises.
At Oxford in the late 1920s, Auden read
the work of Eliot and was inspired majorly by the latter. Auden’s earliest
verse was also influenced by Thomas Hardy and Wilfred Owens. His poems are
fragmented, hinging on substantial images and colloquial concerns to convey
Auden’s political and psychological fears. In the 1930s his poems mirrored his
travels as well as his obsession with the work of Karl Marx and Sigmund Freud. Journey to War,
written with Christopher Isherwood, a regular collaborator, featured short
sonnets and a verse interpretation. The famous Spain, dealing with the Spanish
Civil War, is from this period.
One of the chief factors that sets Auden
different from his lot is his ability to explain matters and topics of sheer
intellect with use of the simplest linguistic facility, easily graspable and
pragmatically structured. A terse description to define Auden as a poet could
be taken from one of his own very brief poems, Epitaph on a Tyrant: Perfection, of a kind, was
what he was after, And the poetry he invented was easy to understand;
He knew human folly like the back of his hand, And was greatly interested in armies and fleets; When he laughed, respectable senators burst with laughter, And when he cried the little children died in the streets The More Loving Oneis a poem by Auden that talks about him looking up at the stars and while examining these, it can be understood that the poet makes significant allusions.
He knew human folly like the back of his hand, And was greatly interested in armies and fleets; When he laughed, respectable senators burst with laughter, And when he cried the little children died in the streets The More Loving Oneis a poem by Auden that talks about him looking up at the stars and while examining these, it can be understood that the poet makes significant allusions.
The “stars” in the poem could allude to
the ruling hierarchy, the upper tiers that rule over masses. It is a substantial
interpretation to the poem that the poet hinges his idea upon; Auden, being the
social analyst that he was, through this poem placed emphasis on the
discordance between the government tiers and the ordinary masses—drawing
people’s attention towards the asymmetrical society—the widening of the gyre
between the bases and the superstructures. It is this ever-widening gap between
the proletariat and the bourgeois class that engenders a social conflict
between the two, which ultimately becomes a cause of the struggle that the
proletariat class undergoes in order to eventually bring a revolution. The poet
refers to himself as the more loving entity, a kind of proverbial glue that
would keep the bases together by forging unity of purpose. This particular notion
is inclined towards critiquing capitalism in which cleavages are formed within
a society, If
equal affection there cannot be, Let the more loving one be me.
The Marxist idea in the poem is brought
under perspective by highlighting what apitalism is capable of doing to a
society, creating factions and divisions within it and polarizing it to a
lethal extent. It is this idea that is mirrored in the tone of the third
stanza: Admirer
as I think I am Of stars that do not give a damn I cannot, now I see them, say
I missed one terribly all day When the working classes and middle classes of a country feel alienated and realize that they have been brutally left on their own, downtrodden and disenfranchised, they stop relying on their elected representatives, the ones that they bestowed their trust upon—their so-called support-systems and the ones that they admired. This paves way for a pro-Marxist ideology to set in, which for the most part, is a revolution brought about by the toiling bases. The poem is partly pessimistic and partly optimistic. The pessimistic part of the poem manifests itself in the last stanza whereby the poet says, Were all stars to disappear or die, I should learn to look at an empty sky It needs to be understood that the poet here is trying to establish the idea that all ‘big stars’ that one admires and deems as his savior and protector are petty in themselves, their shine is transient and short-lived, which is why one should be prepared to open his eyes to witness an empty sky. The empty sky could allude to a society without social hierarchies and class structures. The optimistic approach, however, is closely linked to the very idea of a silver silhouette seen being engendered by an impeccable belief in revolution which would dissolve the anxieties and pressures endured by the working class. Auden is famous for highlighting contemporary issues that were prevalent under totalitarianism under the veneer of lyrical pieces of beauty.
I missed one terribly all day When the working classes and middle classes of a country feel alienated and realize that they have been brutally left on their own, downtrodden and disenfranchised, they stop relying on their elected representatives, the ones that they bestowed their trust upon—their so-called support-systems and the ones that they admired. This paves way for a pro-Marxist ideology to set in, which for the most part, is a revolution brought about by the toiling bases. The poem is partly pessimistic and partly optimistic. The pessimistic part of the poem manifests itself in the last stanza whereby the poet says, Were all stars to disappear or die, I should learn to look at an empty sky It needs to be understood that the poet here is trying to establish the idea that all ‘big stars’ that one admires and deems as his savior and protector are petty in themselves, their shine is transient and short-lived, which is why one should be prepared to open his eyes to witness an empty sky. The empty sky could allude to a society without social hierarchies and class structures. The optimistic approach, however, is closely linked to the very idea of a silver silhouette seen being engendered by an impeccable belief in revolution which would dissolve the anxieties and pressures endured by the working class. Auden is famous for highlighting contemporary issues that were prevalent under totalitarianism under the veneer of lyrical pieces of beauty.
In The Unknown Citizen, Auden describes an
individual who is robed off his individuality in such a way that he has been
displayed as an entity recognizable by the various external agencies that keep
a track of his life: For in everything he did he served the greater Community. Except for
the War till the day he retired He worked in a factory and never got fired, But
satisfied his employers, Fudge Motors Inc. Yet he wasn’t a scab or odd in his
views, For his Union reports that he paid his dues One could argue
over the nature of the title of this poem, it is essential to bear in mind the
reality that the readership is made to imbibe by the poet rightly pointing out
that an individual is nothing but a cog in the social machinery—and this
mechanical existence fosters nothing evolutionary, rather paves way for a life
punctuated by stagnation. As the individual grows older he becomes emotionally
sterilized, transposed into a robot. What the poet means to willfully state is
the abstract notion that any individual, towards the later years of his life in
any society, does not remain the person he was born as.
The Press are convinced that he brought a paper every day And that his reactions to advertisements were
normal in every way The names of all the agencies begin with capitalized
letters, this shows that the poet is hinting at the idea that in societies,
from a bird’s eye view, the individual himself coupled with all his obstinate
pursuits of individuality, is dwarfed by the system that runs the society and
affects the major stakeholders. The major stakeholders could be the mega
institutions, institutionalized norms and major private owners in the
managerial, working apparatus of any country. This again makes the idea of
Marxism very prominent in Auden’s work as it is inexorably this very situation
that results in demarcations and cornering of individuals who are constructive
citizens of the society, demeaned and dwarfed by the big fishes in the game who
not only use their well-established image and infrastructure to crush these
individuals but also use art, religion and politics to exert their influence. Was he happy? Was he free?
The question is absurd.
The absurdity about the question arises
straight from the time when one looks up at the title of the poem, The Unknown Citizen,
ideally the citizen is the state’s responsibility but in the poem, Auden
explains how the state treats the citizen as nothing more than a duty that
needs to be kept a check upon with the help of a few external sources- ensuring
the veritable happiness of the citizen has never been on the state’s list of
priorities. In his poem, In Time of War, Auden gives an in-depth analysis of the
complete process of proto-industrial capitalism. He talks about the various
aspects of capitalism affecting the natural fabric of any country which is
responsible for instilling unity within individuals. In the Engines bear them
through the sky: they’re free And isolated like the very rich;/ Here war is
simple like a monument: A telephone is speaking to a man; Flags on a map assert
that troops were sent; A boy brings milk in bowls.
There is a plan For living men
in terror of their lives, Who thirst at nine who were to thirst at noon, And can be lost and are, and miss their wives,
And, unlike an idea, can die too soon. The effects of capitalism as we see it, the machines
and the mechanical devices are what have reduced the ‘human” in man. Man has
become a prey to dejection feeling strangulated by man-made social orders, the
poet describes how war is itself the biggest of human follies and the biggest
of human failures in essence. It is important to note here that Auden relates
war and the “journey to war” directly with the idea of capitalism. Marxism,
being a binary to capitalism, is what Auden, socially, propagates in this poem.
The rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer, being the hallmark of an
asymmetrical society is what Auden has carried out a spoken battle against. But ideas can be true
although men die/ Requires their skill;
will ever see how flying Is the creation
of ideas they hate, Auden points out here that the valiant skill
with the art of soldering is what the higher authorities require from the
individuals, the citizens, but the ideas dwelling within these mindsets might
be true, Auden throws light at the fact that it is easier to see men dying in a
war but an ideology cannot be buried so plainly.
The perplexity of war is what Auden has talked
about as failure and a futile exercise but at the same time the motivation that
these men have, that provides the impetus for such an exercise in the first
place, is what bears significance in Auden’s eyes and it is this motivation
that Auden defends and revels in. The poet says that it is this motivation that
would make the people actualize their true potential as veritable individuals,
cognizant of the fact that they should not waste their energies on activities
like war, but ought to channelize their energies to bring essential changes to
the very system that creates room for war. In a nutshell, Auden worked not only
as a beautiful poet but as one whose poetry did not do away with creating an
impeccable balance between reasonable excess and required reality, beautiful in
its form, yet practical and poignant in its message.
Modernism is one of the major movements in twentieth
century literature. It registers dramatic breakdown of conventions. World War I
had great and probably everlasting effect on traditional society.
Modernism dares to explore those areas,
which was forbidden for conventional
society: M odernist writing "plunges’ the reader into a confusing and
difficult mental landscape which
cannot be immediately
understood but which
must be moved
through and mapped by the reader
in order to understand its limits and meanings. (Childs 4) For many readers,
modernism is difficult to understand. It
has violated or is still violating all forms of limitation imposed
by victorian or traditional society.
The
present crisis brought by the
catastrophe o f World War I is not reparable: Crisis is inevitably the central term o
f art in discussions o f this turbulent
cultural moment. Overused as it has been, it still glows with justification. This century had scarcely grown used to its own name, before it learned the
twentieth would be the epoch of
crisis, real and manufactured, physical
and metaphysical,
material and symbolic. (Levenson 4) However, many modern writers hope for the
better. Many writers believed that if we could resurrect the former beliefs
then modem land could be saved from the crisis. Unfortunately, after the World
War II writers become hopeless because the War has shattered the traditional beliefs
permanently.
Bibliography
1. Brooks, Jr Cleanth.“The Waste Land: An Analysis” . The Waste Land. Ed.
Michael
North. New York: W.W Norton & Company, 2001
2.
Childs, Peter. Modernism. London: Routledge, 2002
3.
Hirschberg,
Stuart. “Art as the Looking Glass o f Civilzation in W. B. Yeats’s ‘Under Ben Bulben’”
. Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review.
71 .284( Winter, 1982): 399-404
4.
Jeffares, A. Norman.
“The Byzantium Poems o f W.B
Yeats” . The Review of English Studies.
22.85 (January, 1946): 44-52
5.
Levenson,
Michael, “ Introduction”. The
Cambridge Companion To Modernism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
1999
6.
Longenbach,
James. “Modern poetry”. The Cambridge Companion To Modernism. Ed. Michael Levenson. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 1999
7.
Malaney, William D. “T.S
Eliot’s Poetics o f Self:
Responding “Four Quartets” . Alif: Journal o f Comparative Poetics. 22: 14 8 - 168
8.
Mathews, Steven.
T.S Eliot’s Chapman: “ M etaphysical” Poetry and beyond''. Journal o f Oser, Lee. “Charlotte
Eliot and “The Love Song o f J. Alfred Prufrock”” . 94.2(November, 1996):
190-200
9.
Stauffer, Donald
A. “ W. B .Yeats and the Medium o f Poetry”. ELH. 3(September, 1948): 227-246
10. Weitz, Morris.
“T.S Eliot: Time as a Model of Salvation”. The Sewanee Review. 60.1(January-M arch, 1952):
48-64
Appendixes
A.
“The specific
features signified by “modernism” (or by the adjectives modernist) vary with
the user, but many critics agree that it involves a deliberate and radical
break with some o f the traditional bases not only o f Western art, but o f
Western culture in general.” - M. H. Abrams
( English Romantic Poets: modern
essays in criticism (1960) p. 167)
B.
“In relation to
Modernism, modernity is considered to describe a way o f living and of experiencing life which
has arisen with the changes
wrought by industrialisation, urbanisation
and secularisation; its characteristics are disintegration and reformation, fragmentation
and rapid change, emphatically and insecurity. It involves certain new understandings
o f time and space: speed, mobility, communication, travel, dynamism, chaos and
cultural revolution.” (Childs 14-15)
C. Indeed Modernism would seem to be the point at which
the idea o f the radical and innovating arts, the experimental, technical,
aesthetic ideal that had been growing
forward from Romanticism,
reaches formal crisis - in
which myth, structure and organization in a
traditional sense collapse, and not only for formal reasons. (Bradbury and McFarlane -
Modernism: A Guide to European Literature, 1890-1930 )
কোন মন্তব্য নেই:
একটি মন্তব্য পোস্ট করুন